21 comments »

Wake up, real estate bloggers, there is no money in the long tail of search for niche blogs so stop chasing it

Since it seems that the RE Net is slightly behind the eight ball here- lets see if I cant lay out the various arguments for why the long tail should not be targeted and instead should just be a bonus result of chasing the short tail.

long tailI recently had the pleasure of sitting on the panel at RETech and a question about chasing the long tail of search traffic was asked.  It greatly surprised me because chasing the long tail of search traffic has been mostly discredited as a viable means of building transactional readership in the niche blogosphere for the past year.  Since it seems that the RE Net is slightly behind the eight ball here- lets see if I cant lay out the various arguments for why the long tail should not be targeted and instead should just be a bonus result of chasing the short tail.

Read also: The myth of the long tail and the true value of blogging

What is the long tail theory?

Back in 2004 when Chris Anderson came up with the long tail.  He theorized that the future of business is to sell less of more. Collectively, things that are in rather low demand can amount to quite large volumes. So, in the case of Amazon, they would on any given day sell more of all other books combined than they would of those on the bestsellers list.  Makes sense, right?

Why does this make sense?  Because we are talking about a very specific type of product- books- for which there can be many thousands of different individual products.  What happens when you translate the long tail theory of business to search traffic for niche service sites like real estate?  Things get a bit hairy because the types of things people might enter as search criteria to find your site are endless especially if you dont focus your content.  The rub there is that people that wind up on your real estate blog for a long tail search are most likely not transactional visitors.  For example, someone searching for ˜fishing el dorado is not likely to be someone in the market for a home.  Conversely, the short tail ˜long beach real estate or ˜foreclosures for sale in long beach ca search visitors are.  So, the question here is, where do you define the long tail and where do you define the Hail Mary Pass of search? 

(And Todd, yes, these examples are for you- they are real world examples taken from a real client site.  The link love is to a post Todd did interviewing Aaron wall of SEOBook where he basically says what I say about blogrolls- put them on a single page unto themselves not sitewide in your sdiebar.)

Read also: Does Google Hate Your Blogroll?

What is the long tail of search traffic?

When I hear people talking about targeting long tail search terms, I just shake my head.  If all you are after is traffic, then go for it, but if you are after real transactional visitors looking to buy and sell real estate, chase the short tail, your prime real estate related terms.  Seek to drive in traffic that is interested in your offering.  The interesting thing you will find is that by virtue of chasing the short tail with rich well written real estate focused content, you will attract long tail traffic as well.  And if that long tail traffic converts to leads great, if it doesnt you always have the tried and true short tail traffic to support you.

There seems to be a huge misconception as to what the long tail of search really is.  Many people seem to think long tail searches are searches with long strings of words.  While that can be true, the real definition should be any search that only results in one to two new visitors per month and/or is not directly related to your prime keywords.  The short tail of traffic for your blog is your prime terms and terms having to do with real estate. Another way to think about long tail search is that because people’s search habits vary based on age, race, region, linguistical patterns and even psychographics you have to look at the intent of the search not necessarily the words in the search.  If the search is for something related to real estate in your area, then it is a short tail search- if the intent of the search is to find non real estate or hyper local content then it is a longtail search.  Basically, if the searcher intended to land on a real estate site- then you have a short tail search, no matter how long the phrase was they used to get to your result in the SERP.

Lets head on over to SEO Fast Start for this answer to what long tail search traffic is for further clarification.  Over to SEO Fast Start for this answer (He just explains it so well):

˜The ˜long tail of search is very real. Half of the queries in a given month (more or less) are one-offs. One search query for that term. By one person. It should be obvious to those who have read the keyword strategy chapter in SEO Fast Start, that these search terms are:

1.       Not going to show up in any keyword database

2.       Not worth targeting individually

3.       Very easy to ˜target by writing keyword rich copy¦.

Read also: Keyword Strategy Long Tail Myth and Reality

*Notice the last statement about how the long tail search terms are ˜very easy to ˜target by writing keyword rich copy¦.  Hmmm¦ so, by always targeting your key terms and writing rich content, you would by default get long tail search traffic too.  Kind of blows the roof of targeting long tail traffic, doesnt it?

Example of long tail traffic: long tail terms are hilighted in yellow:

Long Tail

Why does chasing the long tail of search work for some general consumer sites and not for niche sites?

Now, lets see why long tail chasing works for other websites.  Lets take for example, one of my favorite blogs, TMZ.  TMZ probably has a lot of long tail traffic.  However, because they have general consumer content (gossip) and they make money off of ads (the more traffic, the more ad displays or clicks), this works for them.  You see, any traffic is good traffic for a site like TMZ.  On the flip side, the only traffic that matters to a real estate site is transactional traffic- meaning those visitors that will hire you to help them buy or sell real estate.  So, why chase down a whole bunch of non transactional traffic by targeting long tail keywords?

Read also: Theres No Money In The Long Tail of the Blogosphere

Why chasing the long tail will not work for real estate blogs

Ultra-niche bloggers (i.e. real estate bloggers) took this long tail theory and ran with it - Ive seen post after post about chasing down the long tail.  Heres the sticky part about the long tail of search in real estate: in the overall search market your local real estate terms are already small potatoes - many of them generating less than 100 searches per day.  You are already competing for low click terms, so why would you spend time writing hundreds of posts that each may only get one visitor per month when you can write 5-10 targeting shorter tail terms that will get 20-50 clicks per month?  The value of the short tail for you is that these visitors searched for something related to real estate and will be interested in what you can offer. 

Tool: Check how many searches your key term gets per day

Even Amazon still focuses their promotional efforts and dollars on the short tail

Now, lets do a little exercise here¦ If Amazon is selling more of all the rest of the books than of the bestsellers, does that mean they spend their time and money promoting the thousands of books that comprise the long tail?  Obviously not.  They still filter their bestsellers to the front page.  Why?    It would be more expensive to actively promote all the books comprising the long tail than to promote the few bestsellers.  So, if a successful online retailer like Amazon still focuses its promotional efforts and dollars on where they will get the most bang for their buck (bestsellers -their short tail) why dont you?  Your time should always be spent on the many searches you can get for a single term instead of the few searches you can get for many terms.   Think about it- to get the volume you need from the long tail- you have to write hundreds or thousands of posts targeting obscure terms.  And because the terms are obscure, you arent guaranteed that the visitors these terms drive in are transactional real estate visitors.

Related Posts
Long tail, short tail and coat tail searches
Feed your real estate blog to the dogs
RSS Pieces wishes you Happy Thanksgiving
HOT STUFF: Sellsius
Ultimate guide to domain names


http://www.rsspieces.com/002AF8
http://www.rsspieces.com/wake-up-real-estate-bloggers-there-is-no-money-in-the-long-tail-of-search-for-niche-blogs-so-stop-chasing-it
Posted on April 16, 2008 10:36:39
Comment from: Carl Martens [Visitor] Email · http://www.auntbrenda.com
*****

I attended the REtechSouth conference and noticed you shook your head in disagreement as another panel member spoke about the longtail…I am glad you wrote this post because you are absolutely right it really doesn’t pay to chase the longtail.  You did an excellent job of explaining this!

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 11:13:30
Comment from: Daniel, the Real Estate Zebra [Visitor] Email · http://realestatezebra.com

Focusing all your efforts on long tail search terms would be a waste of time.  Of course, focusing too much on any type of search term could potentially be a waste of time, depending on how it is done.  If, for example, your focus on your top keywords leads you to write very bad copy that is keyword-stuffed, you are wasting time.  


To me, the best real estate blogs have a healthy mix.  They do this because while buyers might not search for long tail keywords, potential sellers just might.  Sellers already live in the area.  They have little need to search for things like “area x real estate,” or “area x homes for sale.”  They do, however, search for information that is relevant to where they live.  In this respect, posts that aren’t totally about real estate, and instead are intended to be community resources could most certainly be beneficial.  If members of your community recognize your site as a source of information that they cannot otherwise find, guess who just might get a call when those people need real estate help?


Do what it takes to make your site interesting, informative, and sticky.  If writing a few long tail posts enhances those qualities, go for it.  I believe it was Ben Franklin who said that we should practice moderation in all things.  There is no be-all-end-all method.

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 11:22:20
Comment from: Steven [Visitor] Email · http://eastyorktorontorealestate.com

Very well said.  I must have read one of your posts and I started focusing on the short the tail about 8 weeks ago.  Since then I have noticed a I was getting alot more transactional search hits even though I have yet to hit page 1 or 2 for my targeted keywords. 


Steven

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 11:35:42
Comment from: David Small [Visitor] Email · http://www.grandstrandagents.com
*****

Very well said!  Thanks for explaining this.  I was beginning to wonder about the whole long tail phenomenon with so many talking about it lately.  I never could quite understand what all the hype was about.  If I’m trying to sell real estate in Myrtle Beach, I want to attract visitors that are looking for what…real estate in Myrtle Beach!

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 13:02:46
Comment from: Todd Carpenter [Visitor] Email · http://blogfiesta.mariah.com
*****

Mary, I only disagree with you when you’re wrong. :p


No need to assume I would here. Chasing the long tail is a waste of time. Long tail results are just something that happens anyway. Iceing on the cake.


I’ve long said that RE.net is not Web 2.0. by that, I mean that Real Estate agents are not like most bloggers. They don’t sell advertising. The only traffic they need is from consumers who will want to work with them. If it came from a long tail search, hey that’s swell, but that can’t be the focus of a real estate blog


Of course, I’d argue that chasing short tail results is not the single most important strategery either.

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 14:52:56
Comment from: Jonathan Washburn [Visitor] Email · http://activerain.com/jon
**---

Really?  Seriously? Online Real estate search marketing is all about the long tail. That is unless you are in the top .0001 percentile and can get a top three ranking for a short tail term like “Seattle real estate”. The reality is that most of those terms go to long established domain names.



Bob and I were just talking about a post that received a customer call 18 minutes after being posted on ActiveRain for a search term along the lines of “real estate within walking distance from the University of AZ campus”.


Here is a link to the post: http://activerain.com/blogsview/359215/Single-Family-Home-by


And here is a link to the post where the blogger talks about it:http://activerain.com/blogsview/469970/Zero-Comments-Three-New


And regarding the quality of long tail searches: they are generally much higher quality than the short tail searches.  Which search would you rather find your blog:


“Seattle real estate” or “Seattle Queen Anne condo specialist”?


btw: The top two result for “Seattle real estate” are long existing home listing websites.


The top two results for “Seattle Queen Anne condo specialist” are both blogs. One: Raincityguide and two ActiveRain.

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 15:55:11
Comment from: Guest [Visitor] Email · http://www.rsspieces.com
Mary.McKnight

Todd,


Thanks for the agreement.  I also agre that chasing the short tail is not the single most important thing either.



Jonathan,


It doesn’t really strike me from the comment that you even read this post.  The point is when you do research you would see that Seattle Queen Anne condo specialist is not searched even 1 time per day.  So, why would you chase that as a keyword- by simply writing rich copy that contains that word- you would rank for it.  You can still rank for long tail terms but you should never chase it- it doesn’t make any sense. 

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 16:06:21
Comment from: northern indiana real estate [Visitor] Email · http://www.northernindianarealestate.com/

I have never spent time chasing the long tail, it just did not seem like a thing that would really result in sales. Though I will take any long tail traffic that happens to come my way just because you never know.

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 16:13:26
Comment from: ne [Visitor] Email
***--

I think that what you are disputing is not so much the concept of the long tail as the (wrong) application of it. Ignoring the right market in favour of more achievable but less effective ‘markets.’ I disagree that the long tail targeting is wrong. But I do agree that targeting keywords that are ineffective, too rarely searched to justify the effort etc. is not a good idea.


The concept merely states that markets can and are becoming more fragmented


On the supply side:


- businesses or business units do not necessarily need scale to either create product offerings or more importantly market them. In a nutshell, You can now (because of a variety of reasons) market to only 10,000 or 500 or even 10 at a roughly pro-rata cost of creating a campaign targeting 1m. This was not available to most marketers previously. Products no longer have to appeal to everyone. You can create products and/or markerting campaigns aimed at smal percentages of the population.


You are demonstarating this yourself by communicating to ‘real estate
bloggers’ a hopelessly small niche way down the long end of the tail.examples


think of the main industries buying tv advertising. In Australia some ar
- Womens hygien products: (suitable for 25%+ of the population)
- Makeup/cosmetics- (suitable for 25%+ of the population)
- Supermarkets/department stores (suitable for 25%+ of the population)
- Major brand/model cars (suitable for 15%+ of the population)


get where I am going with this?


On the Demand Side


As people are exposed more to those things (cultural activities, marketing etc.) based on their own choices, their wants & needs become more varied and specific demanding more varied and specific products offerings. This is a process that feeds itself.






Application in this case


Applying all this to real estate keyword targeting is tricky. Partly because the above does not always apply to keywords (though it often does) and partly because your starting point is pretty far down the tail. (anyone trying to rank for “real estate USA.”


The long tail is very applicable though in the more interesting area of establishing you readership/customer base. You can be the source for investors looking to buy from flippers, or specific (uncommon) types of real estate, or real estae with planning/zoning issues ….


The move towards long tail means you can establish this audience, communicate, market and profit from them more easily then you could before. Rather then “an everyone can do it” real estate boot camp you can have a “anyone with a law degree and $200K to spend can do it” or a “any engineer/carpentor/plumber can do it”


This may not directly translate into a an SEO or a Google arbitrage strategy but it can translate into a business strategy

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 22:05:35
Comment from: Guest [Visitor] Email · http://www.rsspieces.com
Mary.McKnight

Ne,


Exactly- The long tail exists and it can drive traffic- but to chase it down is a pointless endeavor.


I agree with everything you have to say.  My point exactly is that the locl real estate terms are already so far down in the tail that chasing antyhign beyond that is like chasing your tail.

PermalinkPermalink April 16, 2008 22:13:07
Comment from: Cyndee.Haydon [Member] Email · http://www.clearwaterrealestatetampahomes.com/
*****
Cyndee.Haydon

Mary -  since I’ve been blogging I obviously targeted short tails like Clearwater Florida Real Estate - and  while I’m on page 1 for this term which is a targeted keyword - hittail.com shows me that my “money terms - short tails” only make up 10% of my traffic  anyway- so obviously I get 90% more just by writing my blog.


The biggest difference is that those that hit the blogs via a short tail term are significantly more likely to “search for homes” or “check home values” so they are the best readers to lead to future business - thank goodness for long tails but again I think Jonathan made the point - it takes consistent focus on short tails to compete with the big boys and win - but I know lots of RE bloggers that are doing it and winning! :)        

PermalinkPermalink April 17, 2008 00:29:11
Comment from: Fred Carver [Visitor] Email · http://www.1-victoria-real-estate.com

Hi Mary,


 I have to throw in my two cents, I’ve been online with a real estate web site for about 10 years,am set well on the first page on my city main search term #2 under victoria bc real estate and under 8 under victoria real estate and I have been there a long time.


 I can say a lot have changed, especialy as you know Blogging posts which get listed in Google immediatley for your title and content. Just a little off the RE subject for a moment, I have a client who called to discuss some gardening ideas for him this Summer, as his yard is small. I asked if he liked to grow potatos, he said yes, but thought his yard was two small. I suggested growing them in a barrel, he said he had never done that, how can I find out how to do it? I said to search Google “how to grow potatos on a barrel” (long tail discription) look for it yourself. The top of the page are instructions on growing potatos in a barrel, he also tried just growing potatos but nothing about how to growm them in a barrel.


I submit long tail keyword titles in my blog posting and immediatley get number 1 or close in Google, for such titles as Victoria bc luxury waterfront homes for sale, James bay homes for sale, or post a property as starting with the address in the title then with a long discription such as 303-139 Clarence street two bedroom condo in james bay, I quickly get top position, Which do you think a serious buyer will search Victoria real estate or two bedroom condo in james bay. I have to say I have two listings this month  from using longtail key words. One cancelled his listed after two weeks with another large firm, as the seller could not find his listing online. I was all over the Google page with my long tail key words under james bay real estate for sale.


My main intent is to not only find serious buyers but have a unique listing tool too,I copy my postion on Google and show it at my listing appointments


I think it’s a great listing tool doing long tail key word marketing, sure we need short tail, but the results are not the same, I get a lot of tire kickers from my short tail search term listings on Google


Excuse any typos, have a great day!

PermalinkPermalink April 17, 2008 01:14:13
Comment from: teresa boardman [Visitor] Email · http://www.stpaulrealestateblog.com

My blog comes up number one for St. Paul real estate.  My business comes from the long tail searches, like condos by the river, lofts in St. Paul and the names of various neighborhoods and areas where people want to live. You are right in that people that hit my blog through long tail searches about pumpkin carving contests don’t buy houses but there are many long tail searches that do work when people are looking for information about housing.

PermalinkPermalink April 17, 2008 07:19:11
Comment from: ne [Visitor] Email

The SEO application for long tail theories simply means that you go for less competitive terms.


The reason it is given as generic advice is that in most industries it is good advice.  (if you sell shoes or  wallets or stationary or accounting services….). Real estate agents probably think long tail naturally because they are often localised, so pushing them further in that direction is not a good idea. The limitations of generic advice I suppose.


However, I think that all this still ignores the interesting part of long tail theory in its application to real estate agents, particularly those expiremental enough to be writing a blog (well).


That is reaching the long tail of the market.  Instead of selling a service to the main bulge of the bell, do something else. How many great customers does one agent need? the kind that sell 5 or ten or twenty times per year? the kind that send friends and colleuges to the agent cause ‘she knows her stuff’. the kind they put on the market


That I was able to find this post without remembring who wrote it or when I came across it is a testament to google. This may be of interest to your readers: http://sethgodin.typepad.com/seths_blog/2008/02/advice-for-real.html probably sums it up better then I would.


More speccifically about this topic


Another thing to not is that long tail is about where the center of your focus is. It was (and is)  common for  mainstream  companies to put their main effort on the center of the market and proportonally less effort on the fringes. That is not long tail marketing.


So while having a page on your site and an occasional post about (what is here called) “body corporate with possibilty to subdivide” may not be very unusual to find on a site, it would be uncommon to find a whole site/blog (and coresponding real estate agent) about it. I would assume that someone looking for that sort of a thing (or at least taking note if they do come accross it) is the kind of person who would regularly read a blog, have her own regular real estate agent and  be looking into the finer points the sort of details that require either of these

PermalinkPermalink April 17, 2008 07:28:10
Comment from: Guest [Visitor] Email · http://www.rsspieces.com
Mary.McKnight

Teresa and Fred,


Nowhere in this post did I say you won’t rank for longtail terms.  I am only saying that you can’t chase the long tail in a niche blog like real estate.  You will by default rank for long tail terms (as you should) when you target and chase the short tail. 



Also- the RENet has completely missed the definition of the long tail in search- I explaned what it is very veyr clearly here- some of the examples given by Teresa are not even long tail- based on the intent- they are still short tail.


I wish people would read the post, not just the title. 

PermalinkPermalink April 17, 2008 08:49:04
Comment from: Annie Maloney [Visitor] Email · http://www.anniemaloney.com
*****

Mary~


Excellent explanation.  I don’t consider myself an expert in SEO or Web 2.0 by any means.  But I do make it a point to learn and educate myslef as much as possible.  There is a vary large misconception that the “long tail” of searches is nothing other than just a long, descriptive key word string.  My understanding of the long tail WAS very similar to that, until now.  Thanks.  Judging by nothing other than the title of this post I would have initially said your crazy! (I mean that in the best way) :>).  After having read the article though I can’t agree enough, with the exception of optimizing for particular addresses and streets that are hotspots and/or listings that one may be promoting.  Anyway, thanks again for the clarity.  Bookmarked Ya!

PermalinkPermalink April 18, 2008 10:57:56
Comment from: Chris Fyvie [Visitor] Email · http://www.officesearchtoronto.com
***--

Great article to strategize and get started on a real estate blog.  I really feel bloging is where things will be going in the real estate industry… at least for the next 12 months.

PermalinkPermalink April 18, 2008 11:01:24
Comment from: Brad Nix [Visitor] Email · http://maxsell.net
*****

Historically, I have been a terrible blogger with lack of focus and lack of keywords targeting.  Recently, I have done slightly better at focuing on the short tail.  About two weeks ago I decided to go far “Woodstock Real Estate”.  At the time I was about 60 on the Google list.  Today I come up #17 and hope to be on Page 1 soon.  Granted it’s not “Atlanta Real Estate”, but I do primarily serve the Woodstock suburb of Atlanta.



I suppose I am just babling at this point, but would like to conclude that blogging for the short tail seems easy enough if your goals are not “mega city real estate”.


 


Good post and great comments by everyone!

PermalinkPermalink April 18, 2008 16:18:11
Comment from: Guest [Visitor] Email · http://www.rsspieces.com
Mary.McKnight

Brad,


That was exactly the point of this piece.  If you simply blog to the short tail with rich copy you will attract both short and long tail results.  If, on the other hand, like I have seen- you tell people to blog to the long tail- you can never attract the short tail- which whether anyone wants to admit it or not- short tail searches result in more transactions than long tail searches- no one has ever made the decision to look for 4th of July parades in the morning but come hoem with house- the only simlarity between the 2 being the parade and the house are in the same town. 


I am on board, Brad.  And you stated my point so very very clearly with great experience behind it.


Now that you are 17- try building 10-20 new high quality backlinks to your site with your keyword as the anchor text- you will see an additional spike- those 2 simple things- blogging with short tail keyword richness and building backlinks with quality keyword anchor text are the only 2 real secrets to spanking the SERPs. 

PermalinkPermalink April 18, 2008 16:47:25
Comment from: Dan Thies [Visitor] Email · http://www.seoresearchlabs.com
*****
Mary, this is brilliant. I rarely read posts and say “wow, I wish I’d written that.” But this one, yeah. Just a great explanation of what ‘long tail’ really means in search marketing.

Thanks for this. I’m going to mail a link in my next newsletter.

Amazon, BTW, doesn’t need to target the long tail deliberately - their site is structured so that it takes care of itself on the SEO side. You’ll have a very hard time searching for any book without getting Amazon on the SERP.

They could improve things by leveraging their user-generated content more, but they should do that for conversion purposes anyway.

Amazon’s distribution deals cover them pretty well on the PPC side too.

I have no idea how I wasn’t aware of you before, but I’m on your feed now, and welcome to my blogroll.
PermalinkPermalink April 19, 2008 12:28:58
Comment from: ruthann.macklin [Member] Email · http://www.realestatevirtualassistant.net/
*****
ruthann.macklin

As always, what you say makes complete sense. My husband is a Realtor. His blog (on one of your competitors platforms) was written to chase the long tail. After 1.5 years of blogging 3 times a week, there wasn’t much change in the amount of business we were generating. We moved his blog over to the rsspieces platform 2.5 months ago. I have been following your blogging advice during this time and concentrating on the short tail. At the end of the second month of his blog, we had doubled the number of leads we were generating. Thank you for sharing your wisdom and putting money in our pockets!  


Now I am sharing your wisdom with my other clients (I’m a real estate virtual assistant) and making them money also!

PermalinkPermalink April 25, 2008 01:32:00
Comment on this article


Your email address will not be displayed.


Your URL will be displayed.
Poor Excellent

Standard HTML is allowed in posts

Line breaks become <br />


Remember me


Allow users to contact you through a message form.
Captcha image.

Please enter the characters from the image above. (case insensitive)

This post has 1 feedback awaiting moderation...


real estate blogs

Like what you have been reading on this site?
Subscribe to our feed below.







Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional