Need Ideas to Blog About?
Get better search placement fast
10 comments »Why commenting for traffic and backlinks to your real estate blog is a waste of time
Why is commenting for backlinks or traffic a waste of time?
Read also: Ultimate guide to building backlinks What is the no-follow tag?Applying the no-follow tag to links tells Google not to follow the link which means a link from a blog with the no-follow tag turned on will not be counted as a backlink to your site. 6% of all URLs across the web contain the rel=nofollow attribute. Nofollow attributes are used on a significant percentage of the web's most trusted and authoritative domains. (*source: SEOmoz) How can you tell if the no-follow tag is turned on in a blog?Use SEO for Firefox. When you visit a site with the no-follow tags turned on you will see links highlighted in red. Is all commenting a waste of time?No, I often comment on other blogs to build relationships with the blog owner. For example, when I first entered the real estate world, I commented on a lot of real estate technology and marketing blogs. Why? Because it made a lot of sense for me, as a vendor, to develop relationships with those people. Now, that I am predominately in the entertainment and business blogging sphere, I comment on more music executive, Fortune 500 business, general blogging, copywriting and SEO blogs. Do I comment for backlinks? No. Did I ever? No. Do I get some from time to time. Yes. Do the people I connect with out there mean business to me? Yes. See, it makes sense.
So, let's flip the coin. Where should Realtors be commenting if anywhere?Comment where you know you can get a backlink. Resource: Do Follow Blog List
Your time is valuable. So, use it wisely. Your business is not grown by building relationships with Realtors in Alaska if your business is in West Palm Beach. Also, if you want to build relationships effectively, use a professional networking site like LinkedIn. Why do all the big blogs have their comments turned off?Anyone ever asked why the Google, Pro Blogger and Seth Godin blogs turn their comments off? 1. Because it can be a royal pain in the butt to moderate hundreds of comments daily 2. Because it can dilute the content value and keyword density of a post 3. Because you can get Yahoos in there offering advice that is against the advice of the author or trying to pick a fight 4. Because the content itself is engaging enough that they don't have to build community and relationships through commenting 5. Because services where you can move the comments to a separate site like Sphinn or Digg are more appropriate for large scale consumer blogs with lots of engagement Why do I like my comments on?1. Because I am a niche (real estate professional) blog focused on a small community of early technology adopters that have questions I can typically answer 2. Because when you add a comment to a post, you change the content of the page for me which makes Google interested and lets me be lazy (I don't have to update older posts myself.) Related PostsTHE RULES of commenting for trafficHow to Build Quality Backlinks for your Real Estate Blog, Part 2 How to get .edu backlinks, the holy grail of backlinks HANDLING the angry blogger Comment Smart: 5 simple rules to commenting for backlinks to increase PageRank and SERP Posted in SEO i agree with you on almost everything you write. I purchased seobook in 2003 and it help me understand the engines, then I burnt out from the countless hours of tweaking my sites. I realized that the best way to rank is to produce good content. This works better than tweaking things. i also cant understand why so many repros focus on getting other repros to follow them. commenting is good to get “indexed” but is useless otherwise. However, if they want “readers” a good trackback usually works well since it puts you on the radar for future posts.
Comment from: Kathy Drewien [Visitor] Always appreciate your straightforward approach! Comments are great for building relationships with new folks. Comment from: Lenore Wilkas [Visitor] As usual Mary, you make enormous sense. I can’t see why I want to reach other realtors with what I write. I don’t care what they offer me. I care what my public offers me with questions and eye balls. I keep it local. Thanks for your continued help! Comment from: The Harriman Team [Visitor] I agree with Mary and the others that the main purpose of my blog should be to bring in prospective clients, and I’m aiming for that result. But, being new to blogging, I certainly don’t mind other realtors visiting my blog and commenting. It gives me an additional, sometimes different perspective on things and just maybe I can learn a thing or two from them. And, as far as blogging goes, I still have alot to learn! (That’s why I read RSS Pieces!) Comment from: Carl Martens [Visitor] Well put. Now here’s another question…why do Realtors always backlink to their homepage and not a search or some other call to action page??? Comment from: Jay Thompson [Visitor] “Anyone ever asked why the Google, Pro Blogger and Seth Godin blogs turn their comments off?” (my emphasis) But, the point is still valid.
Another good post Mary. My blog is a “do follow” blog, I grow weary of lame, inane comments that are obviously there for nothing but the backlink. Fortunately I have some great readers and regular commentors who comment to add to the conversation, not for the backlink. And really, I got the same lame comments on occasion when it was a nofollow blog.
Comment from: Mary.McKnight [Member] Jay, You’re right- ProBlogger does have comments on!
I know nothing abut real estate. I am a vendor and I don’t think it would be fair to portray myself as anything other- so I will concede to you on the referral business. I do know that many of our clients do not regularly take in referral business, but you make a valid point about handing it out. The relationship part of commenting is important and I can see where it would be valuable from referrals to recruitment. When I see Realtors commenting for backlinks - I cringe. It is just such a waste of time. If you want to build backlinks- do it the right way- use syndication, directories, linkbait, article submission, basic PR, but commenting… come on. It’s time consuming and not worth the effort. Comment from: Real Estate Your Opinion [Visitor] I am a real estate blogger focused on real estate professionals. I find that a habit of commenting provides the oporutinity to give other participants a taste of the content and commentary that will be found on my blog. I love the heated discussions on some very establsihed blogs out there and am working towards consitently writing engaging content that will bring such discussion to my blog as it continues to grow. I appreciate your posts and opinions, even if I don’t always agree. Thanks for saying the things a lot of us are thinking!
Comment from: Michele [Visitor] Thank you Mary for your help. While doing some research, I ran across a blog post that your readers may find use of. I have to quote the publisher as it is both humorous and pertinent. "Imagine that you go to a presentation after which the lecturer asks for feedback. The person next to you frantically waves their hand in a maniacal effort to get the presenter's attention. Excited at the prospect of a meaningful discussion the lecturer calls on them. "You rock," they say. They hand out their business card and then leave the room never to be seen again." Sound familiar to anyone? The publisher also presents a list of top ten comment etiquette. I have included them here hoping it will help everyone. 1. Write a comment, not spam 2. Stay on topic 3. Respect the rules 4. Comments should be comprehensible 5. Avoid setting the whole blog ablaze when flaming a topic 6. Follow up on comments 7. Keep it to a reasonable length 8. Link to your sources 9. Do not feed the trolls 10. A word about anonymous commenting (full entry at website) The full post can be read at: http: //dariablack.wordpress.com/2007/02/13/the-bloggers-guide-to-comment-etiquette/ I have much to add but will respect rule #7.
Comment from: John, Vancouver WA Homes [Visitor] Thanks again for the incitefull information. My local competition is very much into commenting all over the Internet, while we are trying to be a bit more circumspect with where we spend our keyboard time and the relationships we want to build. Comment on this article This post has no feedback awaiting moderation... |

Like what you are reading here? Then let us email you with all our new content.

Order the eBook
So, I sat on a panel at RETech where we were asked, "How do
you build traffic to your real estate website or blog?" Great question, right? As I strategically sat in the last seat on
the panel, I got to listen as 4 of my peers told an audience of tech savvy
Realtors that you build traffic by commenting on other blogs, putting blogrolls
on your site and joining social networks. Hmmm... call me crazy, but doesn't that
just garner you a whole lot of other Realtors coming to your site? Is that really all that useful to you? Does most of your business come from other
Realtor referrals? Do you relish
splitting a commission with another Realtor for a referral fee when you do most
of the work? I know the Realtors we work
with very rarely take in referrals so that kind of traffic would be totally
useless to them. Needless to say, my
answer to the panel question, as usual, bucked the system: "I must be simple, but I don't much care if
your real estate sites gets 500 visitors that are other Realtors, I care that
you get 500 consumer visitors. So,
here's my suggestion, build high quality backlinks from directories, RSS feed
submissions and linkbait. Write high
quality real estate focused, hyper-local, keyword rich content. Don't waste
your valuable time commenting on blogs that likely have the no-follow tag
turned on, don't join every social network under the sun (be strategic in your
choices). Be smart- get indexed by
Google for short tail keywords and watch the consumer traffic flow in." Commenting simply isn't going to build you business, it may garner you some Realtor traffic, but that isn't the transactional traffic you are after! Does that make sense to you?
Posted in